What a Certificate of Analysis Really Tells You
Six checks to read a peptide lab report: what it proves, what it can't, and what "99 percent pure" really means.
Every supplier says "third-party tested." The great ones prove it: they post a lab report for every batch, and they want you to read it.
Then you open one: a spiky chart, a table of numbers, words like "HPLC" and "Dalton." Plenty of people close it right there, not sure what they're looking at.
Let's open it together. It's easier than it looks.
A Receipt, Not a Review
A Certificate of Analysis, or COA, is a lab report for one batch. It says: we tested this specific lot, with these methods, and found these results. Think of it as a receipt. A real COA is specific and a little boring, and that's a good sign; vague is the warning sign. And like a receipt, it only covers what's on it.
Why it matters: when researchers have bought peptides from illegal online pharmacies and tested them, the labels often haven't held up. A 2018 Belgian study of ten peptide drugs from suspected illegal websites found amounts that varied widely, purity as low as 5 percent, and toxic metals in several. In a 2024 study, three semaglutide vials sold with claims of at least 99 percent purity held 29 to 39 percent more semaglutide than their labels said.
Those were illegal sellers, so this isn't proof that every seller is bad. It is proof that a label can't vouch for itself. That's exactly why the best sellers test every batch and publish the results. Reading that paperwork well is how you tell them apart.
Six Checks, Sixty Seconds
- Find the purity, and the picture. Purity is usually measured by HPLC, which separates whatever is in the sample and draws it as peaks; the purity number is the main peak's share of everything the test picks up. Think of a skyline: you want one tall tower and nearly flat ground. A skyline crowded with little buildings means impurities or breakdown, whatever the headline number claims, so a good COA shows the actual chart (the chromatogram), not just the number. "Research grade" isn't an official standard, so go by the report for that batch and look for 99 percent or higher; a purity claim on a website isn't a test result.
- Confirm identity, not just purity. Here's the part most people miss. HPLC can tell you a sample is 99 percent one thing without telling you what the thing is. A batch made with one amino acid missing can still show one clean tower, score 99 percent, and be 0 percent the right peptide. That's where mass spectrometry comes in: it weighs the molecule itself. The COA should list the expected mass and the measured mass, and they should agree within about one Dalton (the unit molecules are weighed in), the target a U.S. Pharmacopeia expert panel recommended for peptide drug ingredients. Even the smallest amino acid adds 57 Daltons to a chain, so a missing one can't hide in a close match. One limit: the right amino acids in the wrong order weigh the same, and so do a few look-alike swaps; catching those takes deeper tests (one is often written MS/MS).
- Name the lab. Third-party means an independent laboratory, named on the document, checkable in the real world. Look for ISO/IEC 17025 accreditation: an outside body has checked that the lab can do specific tests well, though it can't vouch for any one report. Look the lab up in the accreditor's own directory (A2LA is one U.S. accreditor; ILAC's website lists them by country), and check that the test on the COA is on the lab's accredited list, called its scope. A PDF can be copied or edited, so confirm the report with the lab too, through its website or contact details you found yourself, not the ones printed on the PDF. In-house COAs aren't worthless, but an independent lab is stronger proof, and the best sellers use one. It's question two from our guide to telling if a health claim is real: who's behind it?
- Check the date and the method. When was the test run? An old report can't tell you how the batch has held up since. How was it run? Column, method, wavelength. The best COAs show the method right next to the results.
- Understand what purity doesn't mean. "99 percent pure" is a chromatography result, not a promise that 99 percent of the vial by weight is peptide. Salt and water count: lab-made peptides usually come out as salts (often with a leftover acid called TFA) and hold some water, and HPLC purity counts none of that. A complete COA reports net peptide content separately. Purity isn't the amount, either. In that 2024 semaglutide study, the researchers' own chart showed semaglutide and no other peptides. Yet semaglutide was only about 8 to 14 percent of the powder's weight (the researchers couldn't pin down the rest), and every vial held more of it than its label said.
What a COA Covers
A good COA tells you what a lab found in a sample from that batch: whether it's the right molecule, and how pure. That's real, and it's the foundation of quality. But it only covers the tests on it. For the next layer, look for sterility and endotoxin testing too; the most careful sellers publish those as well. They're separate tests. Sterility testing looks for live germs. Endotoxin testing looks for bits of bacteria that can cause fever and serious reactions. They're released when bacteria die, so they can be there even when nothing is alive. In that 2024 study, none of the vials had live germs, but one carried a high level of endotoxin.
And remember what any lab report is: a quality check, not a medical approval. Whether something is right for you is still a conversation with your doctor.
Why a Mother Should Care
Because the thinking behind these six checks works far beyond peptides: in the supplement aisle, on a skincare ad, at a wellness clinic. Batch-specific testing. An independent lab. Identity, not just purity. Numbers with methods attached. Once you know what proof looks like, a glossy claim gets a lot less convincing, and that's a skill that helps your whole family.
Use these six checks on any product you ever consider, from any company, and bring what you find to your clinician.
This article is education, not medical advice. Talk to your doctor before starting, stopping, or changing anything.
Read next: "Research Use Only": What It Means and Why It Matters
The Series
30 articles- 9. How to Spot a Real Health Claim
- 10. Peptides in Five Minutes
- 11. Reading a Certificate of Analysis
- 12. What "Research Use Only" Means
Sources & references (10)
- Janvier S, Cheyns K, Canfyn M, et al. "Impurity profiling of the most frequently encountered falsified polypeptide drugs on the Belgian market." Talanta, 2018 — Talanta, 2018 · DOI: 10.1016/j.talanta.2018.06.023
- Ashraf AR, Mackey TK, Vida RG, et al. "Multifactor Quality and Safety Analysis of Semaglutide Products Sold by Online Sellers Without a Prescription: Market Surveillance, Content Analysis, and Product Purchase Evaluation Study." Journal of Medical Internet Research, 2024 — Journal of Medical Internet Research, 2024 · DOI: 10.2196/65440
- McCarthy D, Han Y, Carrick K, et al. "Reference Standards to Support Quality of Synthetic Peptide Therapeutics." Pharmaceutical Research, 2023 (USP and MHRA scientists) — Pharmaceutical Research, 2023 · DOI: 10.1007/s11095-023-03493-1
- Swietlow A, Rode H, Szajek A, Verlander M, Eggen I, Gregg B (USP Therapeutic Peptides Expert Panel). "Control Strategies for Synthetic Therapeutic Peptide APIs, Part I: Analytical Considerations." Pharmaceutical Technology, 2014 — Pharmaceutical Technology, 2014
- ISO/IEC 17025: General requirements for the competence of testing and calibration laboratories — International Organization for Standardization, 2017
- A2LA directory of accredited organizations (ISO/IEC 17025) — A2LA
- ILAC MRA signatory search (find a country's accreditation body) — ILAC
- ILAC. "Accredited Conformity Assessment Bodies" (how to confirm a lab's accreditation and scope) — ILAC
- Sikora K, Jaśkiewicz M, Neubauer D, Migoń D, Kamysz W. "The Role of Counter-Ions in Peptides: An Overview." Pharmaceuticals, 2020 — Pharmaceuticals (MDPI), 2020 · DOI: 10.3390/ph13120442
- FDA Inspection Technical Guide No. 32. "Pyrogens, Still a Danger" — U.S. Food and Drug Administration, 1979
This article is education, not medical advice. If you're struggling, call or text 988, or call Postpartum Support International at 1-800-944-4773.
Which peptide guide is yours?
Five quick questions, and we'll point you to the guides that fit what you want help with.
- Your mom type, and what it says about you
- Three articles picked for your answers
- Emails that fit your life, not everyone's
How old is your youngest?
Free · about 60 seconds. Your results come by email right away, then a short email every few days, then the Sunday Letter. Unsubscribe anytime.
More in The Series
Selank and Semax, the Russian "Brain Peptides": What Moms Should Know
October 12, 2026 · Here's what Selank and Semax are, what the small Russian studies and a 2026 FDA review really found, and what helps a racing, foggy mom brain right now.
NAD+, the "Energy Molecule": What Moms Should Know
October 12, 2026 · What NAD+ really is (hint: not a peptide), what the human studies actually tested, and what helps when you're tired all the time.
DSIP, the "Deep Sleep" Peptide: What Moms Should Know
October 12, 2026 · Here's what DSIP is, what the small, decades-old studies on sleep really found, and what actually helps when you're running on broken nights.
Discussion
Loading comments…